Lermoyez Syndrome and Tumarkin Crisis: Rare Meniere’s Variants

Most patients with Meniere’s disease follow a recognizable pattern: vertigo attacks accompanied by hearing loss, tinnitus, and aural fullness. But in my practice across Hardoi and UP, I occasionally encounter patients who don’t fit this typical pattern. Their symptoms are unusual, sometimes paradoxical, and if I’m not thinking clearly, I can misdiagnose them. Today, I want to discuss two rare Meniere’s variants that deserve your attention: Lermoyez syndrome and Tumarkin’s crisis.

These variants are uncommon but important to recognize because they require different management approaches than classic Meniere’s disease, and in the case of Tumarkin crisis, they represent a medical emergency due to injury risk. Missing these diagnoses delays proper treatment and leaves patients suffering unnecessarily.

Related Reading

• Meniere’s Disease: Complete Guide to Symptoms, Diagnosis and Treatment
• Traveling with Vertigo? The 5-Minute Motion Sickness Hack
• Lermoyez Syndrome and Tumarkin’s Crisis: Unusual Meniere’s Disease Variants
• Meniere’s Disease Symptoms and Stages: Full Progression Guide
• Meniere’s and Tinnitus: Managing Hearing Problems Together

Lermoyez Syndrome: The Reverse Meniere’s

Lermoyez syndrome is one of the most counterintuitive diagnoses in otology. Imagine this: a patient comes to me complaining of tinnitus and aural fullness for days, constant without episodes of acute vertigo. Then suddenly, unexpectedly, they have a severe vertigo attack. During or immediately after this attack, something remarkable happens: their hearing improves, sometimes dramatically. The tinnitus that was present for days suddenly quiets or disappears. The sense of aural fullness clears.

This is the opposite of classic Meniere’s disease. In classic Meniere’s, an attack causes vertigo, and sometimes the hearing worsens during the attack or remains unchanged. In Lermoyez syndrome, the attack actually brings hearing improvement. It’s as if the endolymphatic pressure that was building up finally releases during the vertigo episode, relieving the hearing and tinnitus symptoms.

I had a patient from Lucknow, a retired government official, who described it perfectly: “Doctor, I would wake up with my ears feeling full and ringing constantly. For a few days this would go on. Then suddenly one afternoon, I’d feel terribly dizzy, vomit for an hour, and when it was over, I could hear clearly again and the ringing was gone. It was like my ear had been holding its breath and finally let it out.”

This patient had seen three previous doctors who diagnosed her with classic Meniere’s disease and were confused by the hearing improvement after attacks. Once I recognized the pattern, her management became clearer, and we could explain to her what was happening. Her anxiety decreased significantly once she understood that her hearing improving was actually a predictable part of her condition.

Lermoyez syndrome is rare-probably less than 5% of Meniere’s patients-but when I see this pattern, the diagnosis is usually clear. The key diagnostic feature is the hearing improvement that correlates temporally with vertigo attacks. This is different from the hearing fluctuation of classic Meniere’s, where hearing might improve or worsen independent of attacks.

Why Lermoyez Syndrome Happens: Detailed Pathophysiology

The mechanism is interesting. In Lermoyez syndrome, we think there’s a particularly high degree of endolymphatic pressure buildup between attacks. The hearing loss and tinnitus represent this pressure’s effects on cochlear function. When the vertigo attack occurs, it represents a sudden decompression or rupture of the endolymphatic system-essentially, the pressure finally releases. The sudden decrease in endolymphatic pressure allows the cochlear function to normalize quickly, hence the hearing improvement.

Some theorists suggest that in Lermoyez syndrome, there might be an actual micro-rupture of the endolymphatic membrane during the attack-a brief opening that allows fluid mixing between perilymph and endolymph, pressure equalization, and therefore sudden hearing improvement. Think of it like a pressure valve finally giving way and releasing built-up pressure. The perilymphatic fistula-like effect temporarily allows pressure normalization.

This theory explains why the hearing often returns to better levels after attacks in Lermoyez syndrome-the pressure release actually allows the sensory structures to recover function temporarily. The hearing loss in the pre-attack phase comes from mechanical stiffness of the cochlear membrane due to pressure; once pressure releases, the membrane can move freely again.

The cochlea in Lermoyez syndrome is actually functional, just compressed by pressure. It’s not damaged. That’s why when pressure releases, function returns. This is different from classic Meniere’s where some cochlear damage is permanent.

👉 Also read: Low Sodium Diet Meniere India

Tumarkin’s Crisis: The Drop Attack, Sudden and Dangerous

While Lermoyez syndrome is characterized by unusual hearing changes, Tumarkin’s crisis is characterized by unusual balance symptoms that are particularly dangerous. A Tumarkin crisis, also called a Tumarkin drop attack, is a sudden fall without warning, without preceding vertigo, without dizziness. The patient simply loses consciousness of balance and falls to the ground.

Imagine you’re walking through the bazaar in Hardoi, shopping, feeling completely fine, and suddenly you fall to the ground for no apparent reason. You didn’t trip, you didn’t feel dizzy beforehand, you just fell. This is a Tumarkin drop attack. One patient I saw from rural UP fell while walking to the well. She fell with no warning, was found by her daughter, and had a Complete hip fracture requiring surgery. These are serious, life-threatening events.

The danger is obvious. Falls cause injuries. I’ve had elderly patients sustain fractures from drop attacks. A patient fell off a bus during a drop attack and broke several ribs. Another patient fell on concrete stairs and fractured her arm in two places. A third patient hit his head during a drop attack and required CT scan to exclude intracranial bleeding. Tumarkin attacks are medically dangerous and require aggressive management.

What makes drop attacks so insidious is their unpredictability and lack of warning. A patient can’t prepare, can’t lie down beforehand, can’t even brace for impact. The fall is sudden and unexpected, leaving the patient vulnerable to serious injury. This unpredictability causes significant anxiety in patients-many become afraid to leave the house.

Mechanism of Drop Attacks: Otolithic Crisis Explained

The mechanism of Tumarkin attacks is thought to involve sudden changes in endolymphatic pressure affecting the otolithic organs (utricle and saccule)-the sensors for gravity and linear acceleration. These organs contain sensory epithelium with hair cells that detect head position and gravity. A sudden surge of endolymphatic pressure can cause sudden deflection of the otolithic membrane, sending an abnormal signal to the brain about the gravitational direction. The brain responds by trying to correct for this false signal, causing sudden loss of balance and falling.

The attack is essentially a sudden, severe vertigo that happens so fast the patient doesn’t even perceive the sensation of spinning-they just lose balance and fall. It’s the most dangerous form of vertigo because there’s no time to lie down or stabilize. This is why it’s called an “otolithic crisis”-the problem is specifically in the organs detecting gravity, not just rotational motion.

Drop attacks are more common in advanced, long-standing Meniere’s disease, particularly in patients with severe endolymphatic hydrops. They’re thought to represent a more severe form of the disease or a more severe endolymphatic pressure dynamic. The more pressurized the inner ear fluid becomes, the more likely sudden pressure spikes will trigger a drop attack.

Some researchers believe the drop attack represents a sudden reversal of endolymphatic pressure in the saccule specifically. The saccule is the organ detecting vertical acceleration. A sudden pressure surge can completely overwhelm the saccular hair cells, causing complete loss of vertical orientation and falling. The patient falls because their brain suddenly believes the gravity direction has reversed or changed dramatically.

Hip Fractures and Fall Injuries in Indian Elderly Population

This is particularly relevant in India where osteoporosis is common in elderly women (due to high rates of vitamin D deficiency and low dietary calcium) and where many elderly live in multi-story homes with stairs. A Tumarkin drop attack in an elderly woman with osteoporosis is a potential tragedy. Hip fractures in elderly lead to immobility, infection risk, and high mortality. I had one 68-year-old patient with Tumarkin attacks who sustained a hip fracture from a fall and spent three months in bed. She developed pneumonia from immobility and nearly died. Controlling her drop attacks through aggressive treatment became very important.

For this reason, Tumarkin attacks in elderly patients warrant very aggressive treatment-potentially even elective surgery to reduce endolymphatic pressure-to prevent the catastrophic falls that elderly patients cannot survive. A hip fracture in an elderly patient can be the beginning of a downhill course. Prevention is absolutely critical.

👉 Also read: Electrocochleography Meniere

Frequency and Predictability Patterns

Drop attacks are typically not predictable. They occur without warning and without preceding symptoms. This unpredictability is what makes them so dangerous. A patient can’t prepare themselves, can’t lie down before the attack. The attack just happens.

Frequency varies dramatically. Some patients have clusters of drop attacks over several days then none for months. Others have sporadic isolated attacks. Some patients have frequent drop attacks that completely disable them and make them afraid to leave the house.

I had one patient who had three drop attacks in a week and became essentially housebound from fear. She couldn’t work, couldn’t do her daily activities, couldn’t even help her grandchildren because of fear of falling and injuring them. Treatment that controlled the drop attacks essentially gave her her life back. She returned to normal activity, regained her confidence, and resumed caring for her grandchildren. The transformation was remarkable.

In contrast, Lermoyez syndrome has a more predictable pattern-the pre-attack phase with tinnitus and fullness, followed by the attack, followed by hearing improvement. This predictability is actually somewhat reassuring to patients who know the attack will bring relief.

Diagnosis of These Variants: Clinical Approach

Diagnosis is clinical. For Lermoyez syndrome, I look for the specific pattern: hearing loss and tinnitus unrelated to vertigo attacks, but with dramatic improvement during or immediately after attacks. Audiometric correlation is helpful-audiograms showing hearing improves after attacks confirm the diagnosis. I sometimes recommend that Lermoyez patients get audiograms during their pre-attack phase (when tinnitus and aural fullness are prominent) and again after an attack to document the hearing improvement objectively.

For Tumarkin crisis, diagnosis is based on history-reported sudden falls without preceding vertigo. These are rare enough and specific enough that when patients describe them, the diagnosis is usually clear. Vestibular testing might show evidence of advanced Meniere’s disease with reduced or absent vestibular responses and high pressure sensitivity on electrocochleography, but drops attacks are primarily a clinical diagnosis based on the specific symptom pattern described by the patient.

Eliciting this history requires careful questioning. Many patients don’t even remember falling-they just remember suddenly being on the ground. Family members might need to describe what they observed. I always ask Meniere’s patients directly: “Have you ever suddenly fallen to the ground without warning?” The answer to this specific question identifies Tumarkin attacks reliably.

Treatment Differences and Escalation Protocols

Both Lermoyez syndrome and Tumarkin crisis usually respond to the standard Meniere’s treatments: diet, diuretics, intratympanic injections. However, Tumarkin attacks are particularly dangerous, so I escalate treatment more aggressively.

For Tumarkin crisis patients, I move more quickly to intratympanic injections if diet and diuretics don’t control attacks within weeks. I might even consider an ototoxic antibiotic injections sooner than I would for classic Meniere’s, because the fall risk is significant and debilitating. With an ototoxic antibiotic, we accept some additional hearing loss to prevent dangerous falls-a worthwhile trade-off in this dangerous situation.

For Lermoyez syndrome, treatment is similar to classic Meniere’s, though some patients find the pattern reassuring-they know that if they wait out the attack, their hearing will actually improve. This psychological benefit can be significant. Instead of dreading attacks as a patient with classic Meniere’s does (where attacks bring hearing loss), a Lermoyez patient might feel more accepting of attacks because they know hearing will improve afterward.

👉 Also read: Meniere Disease Symptoms

Real Cases from UP Region: Clinical Examples

In my practice across Uttar Pradesh, I’ve encountered several memorable cases of these variants. One patient from Kanpur had Lermoyez syndrome for over a decade. We managed her with diet and diuretics, and she lived with the knowledge that her hearing would always recover after attacks. When we started her on diuretics, the frequency of attacks decreased markedly, and the pattern became more stable and predictable. Her anxiety decreased because she understood her condition and could anticipate the improvement that would follow each attack.

I had another patient from UP who had severe Tumarkin drop attacks. He had fallen three times in one month, including once where he hit his head and nearly had a subdural hematoma. I escalated his treatment immediately to intratympanic injections. After three steroid injections, his drop attacks stopped completely. His quality of life improved dramatically because he could finally go outside without fear of unpredictably falling. He returned to work in his family’s agricultural business and regained his independence and self-confidence.

A third case involved a 72-year-old woman with Lermoyez features who had never been properly diagnosed. She had suffered for five years with pre-attack symptoms before learning about her condition. Once we explained what was happening and predicted the improvement that would follow attacks, her anxiety decreased significantly. She learned to manage her condition and even found some predictability in the pattern. This demonstrates how powerful proper diagnosis is for psychological well-being.

Management Differences from Classic Meniere’s Disease

Lermoyez Syndrome: Hearing improves during/after attacks (opposite of classic Meniere’s); treat as standard Meniere’s; psychological reassurance important as patients know hearing will improve; attacks might be more acceptable psychologically

Tumarkin Crisis: Sudden falls without preceding vertigo (different symptom pattern); aggressive treatment required; intratympanic injections considered sooner; fall prevention is very important; safety precautions essential; elderly patients at very high risk of complications

Classic Meniere’s Disease: Hearing worsens or fluctuates independent of attacks; slower progression in treatment escalation acceptable; attacks are spontaneous and unpredictable

Both variants: Often indicate more severe underlying endolymphatic hydrops; demand higher-intensity treatment; require specialist recognition for proper diagnosis

When to Consider Surgical Options

For Tumarkin attacks that don’t respond to conservative medical management, surgical options include endolymphatic sac decompression, labyrinthectomy, or vestibular nerve section. These are aggressive approaches but may be warranted in patients with frequent, disabling drop attacks that create fall risk and prevent normal functioning.

For Lermoyez syndrome, surgery is rarely needed as the condition often responds well to medical management. However, if attacks become frequent and disabling despite medication, surgical intervention can be considered.

FAQs About These Variants

Are Lermoyez and Tumarkin more common than classic Meniere’s?

No, both are significantly rarer. Classic Meniere’s is the common pattern. These variants occur in maybe 5-10% of Meniere’s patients combined.

👉 Also read: Intratympanic Injections Menieres Disease

Do these variants have different prognosis?

Not necessarily worse long-term, but Tumarkin attacks are immediately dangerous due to fall risk. Both may indicate more advanced disease. However, with aggressive treatment, prognosis can be quite good.

Can a patient have both Lermoyez and Tumarkin features?

Theoretically possible though I haven’t seen it. Both would indicate severe, unpredictable endolymphatic dysfunction requiring very aggressive management.

Should drop attack patients avoid going outside?

Not permanently, but they should take precautions: avoid heights, avoid situations where a fall would be dangerous (like standing at the edge of a railway platform, near stairs). With treatment, drop attacks often resolve and patients regain confidence. Until then, safety modifications are essential.

Is there surgery specifically for drop attacks?

Not specifically. General Meniere’s surgery (labyrinthectomy, vestibular nerve section, endolymphatic sac surgery) helps by reducing the overall severity of inner ear pathology. The goal is to reduce the endolymphatic pressure surges that cause drops.

How quickly can drop attacks be treated?

This is an emergency situation. If a patient presents with Tumarkin drop attacks, I start treatment immediately-steroids systemically, intratympanic injections within weeks, diuretics. The goal is to reduce attack frequency rapidly to prevent injuries.

Can hearing actually improve with Lermoyez attacks?

Yes, this is the defining feature. Temporary improvement in hearing is the characteristic pattern. The mechanism is sudden pressure release allowing cochlear function to recover temporarily. It’s remarkable when you first see it happen.

Will my Lermoyez attacks ever stop?

Some patients with Lermoyez syndrome have attacks that gradually decrease in frequency with diet and medication. However, complete remission is not guaranteed. The goal is to minimize frequency and impact on quality of life.

---

Specialized Meniere’s Care

If your Meniere’s symptoms don’t seem to follow the typical pattern, or if you’re experiencing dangerous drop attacks, reach out to Prime ENT Center. We can properly diagnose these variants and initiate appropriate treatment to restore your safety and quality of life. Don’t accept a generic Meniere’s diagnosis if your symptoms don’t fit-proper diagnosis leads to proper treatment.

---

Medical Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice, diagnosis or prescribing guidance. All medications must be taken under direct supervision of a qualified physician. Consult Dr. Prateek Porwal at Prime ENT Center, Hardoi for personalised treatment.

References

1. Committee on Hearing and Equilibrium guidelines for the diagnosis and evaluation of therapy in Meniere’s disease. Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery. 1995;113(3):181–185.
2. Thirlwall AS, Kundu S. Diuretics for Ménière’s disease or syndrome. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2006;(3):CD003599.
3. Pullens B, van Benthem PP. Intratympanic an ototoxic antibiotic for unilateral Menière’s disease or syndrome. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2011;(3):CD008234.

This article is for educational purposes. Please consult Dr. Prateek Porwal at Prime ENT Center, Hardoi for personal medical advice.

Dr. Prateek Porwal is an ENT & Vertigo Specialist with over 13 years of experience, holding MBBS (GSVM Medical College), DNB ENT (Tata Main Hospital), and CAMVD (Yenepoya University). He is the originator of the Bangalore Maneuver for Anterior Canal BPPV and has published research in Frontiers in Neurology and IJOHNS. Serving at Prime ENT Center, Hardoi.

Reference: Meniere Disease — Sajjadi & Paparella, 2008