Supine Roll Test: Diagnosing Horizontal Canal BPPV
If you’ve been experiencing severe vertigo when you roll over in bed from side to side, but your doctor says your Dix-Hallpike test was negative, you might have horizontal canal BPPV. The Supine Roll Test (also called the Pagnini-McClure maneuver) is the definitive diagnostic test for this variant of BPPV, which accounts for 15-30% of all BPPV cases.
At Prime ENT Center, I perform the Supine Roll Test on every patient with suspected BPPV who has a negative Dix-Hallpike test. Understanding horizontal canal BPPV is crucial because it requires completely different treatment than the more common posterior canal type.
đ Negative Dix-Hallpike But Still Dizzy?
Dr. Prateek Porwal specializes in diagnosing ALL variants of BPPV including horizontal canal involvement.
đ Complete vestibular testing available at Prime ENT Center, Hardoi
What is Horizontal Canal BPPV?
To understand the Supine Roll Test, you first need to understand horizontal canal BPPV (HC-BPPV). Your inner ear contains three semicircular canals arranged in different planes:
- Posterior canal (80% of BPPV cases)
- Horizontal canal (15-30% of BPPV cases)
- Anterior canal (1-5% of BPPV cases)
In horizontal canal BPPV, calcium carbonate crystals (otoconia) become dislodged and migrate into your horizontal semicircular canal. Because this canal is oriented differently than the posterior canal, you experience vertigo with different head movementsâprimarily when rolling in bed from side to side.
Why Horizontal Canal BPPV is Different
HC-BPPV has several distinctive features:
- More intense vertigo: Many patients report that horizontal canal BPPV causes more severe symptoms than posterior canal BPPV
- Different triggers: Primarily triggered by rolling in bed, less often by looking up or bending forward
- Two variants: Geotropic (90%) and apogeotropic (10%) with completely different treatments
- Higher recurrence rate: Tends to recur more frequently than posterior canal BPPV
- Can coexist: Occasionally patients have both horizontal and posterior canal BPPV simultaneously
When Dr. Porwal Performs the Supine Roll Test
I perform this test when:
- Patient reports severe vertigo when rolling in bed
- Dix-Hallpike test is negative but BPPV is still suspected
- Patient describes horizontal head movements triggering vertigo
- Previous BPPV treatment was effective but symptoms have returned with a different pattern
- Patient has atypical nystagmus patterns on Dix-Hallpike suggesting canal conversion
How the Supine Roll Test is Performed
Let me walk you through the step-by-step procedure:
Step 1: Starting Position
You’ll lie flat on your back on the examination table with your head in a neutral position (looking straight at the ceiling). Unlike the Dix-Hallpike test, your head doesn’t extend beyond the table edgeâit remains supported throughout.
Step 2: First Head Turn (90° to One Side)
I’ll rapidly turn your head 90 degrees to one side (let’s say the right side first). Your nose will now be pointing toward your right shoulder. This movement should be relatively quick but controlledâcompleted in about 1-2 seconds.
Observation period: I’ll hold your head in this position for 20-30 seconds while carefully watching your eyes for nystagmus.
What you might experience:
- Brief delay (1-5 seconds latency) before vertigo starts
- Intense spinning sensation
- The spinning typically lasts 10-60 seconds
- Nausea in some cases
Step 3: Return to Center
After symptoms subside, I’ll bring your head back to the center (neutral) position and wait 30-60 seconds for complete recovery.
Step 4: Second Head Turn (90° to Opposite Side)
Now I’ll rapidly turn your head 90 degrees to the opposite side (left). Again, I’ll observe for 20-30 seconds watching for nystagmus and noting your symptoms.
The critical finding: In horizontal canal BPPV, you’ll typically experience vertigo and nystagmus on BOTH sides, but one side will be stronger than the other.
Step 5: Determining the Affected Ear
Here’s where it gets interesting: the side that produces the STRONGER nystagmus response is the affected ear. This seems counterintuitive to many patients who assume the affected side would be the one that causes less symptoms, but in HC-BPPV, the physics of crystal movement makes the affected side produce the more vigorous response.
đ„ Watch Dr. Porwal Perform the Supine Roll Test
See the test procedure and understand what to expect
What We’re Looking For: Geotropic vs Apogeotropic
The key to interpreting the Supine Roll Test is understanding the nystagmus pattern. There are two distinct variants of horizontal canal BPPV:
Geotropic Nystagmus (90% of HC-BPPV Cases)
Definition: “Geotropic” means “toward the ground.” When I turn your head to the right, your eyes beat toward the ground (to the right). When I turn your head to the left, your eyes beat toward the ground (to the left).
What this means:
- Loose otoconia crystals floating in the canal (canalithiasis)
- More common variant
- Generally easier to treat
- Responds well to BBQ Roll maneuver
How to identify the affected ear: The side with STRONGER geotropic nystagmus is the affected ear. If the right side produces more vigorous nystagmus and vertigo, the problem is in your right horizontal canal.
Apogeotropic Nystagmus (10% of HC-BPPV Cases)
Definition: “Apogeotropic” means “away from the ground.” The nystagmus beats in the opposite direction from what you’d expectâwhen your head is turned right, eyes beat to the left (up, away from the ground).
What this means:
- Crystals are stuck to the cupula (cupulolithiasis)
- Less common variant
- Can be more challenging to treat
- Requires Gufoni maneuver or modified treatments
How to identify the affected ear: The side with WEAKER apogeotropic nystagmus is the affected ear (opposite of geotropic!).
Other Nystagmus Characteristics
Just like the Dix-Hallpike test, I’m looking for:
- Latency: 1-5 second delay before nystagmus starts
- Duration: Self-limiting, lasts 10-60 seconds
- Fatigability: Decreases in intensity with repeated testing
- Horizontal direction: Purely horizontal nystagmus (unlike the upbeat-torsional of posterior canal BPPV)
If the nystagmus lacks these featuresâfor example, no latency, no fatigability, or vertical componentsâI become concerned about central nervous system pathology rather than BPPV.
Interpreting Your Supine Roll Test Results
Positive Test for Geotropic HC-BPPV
Findings:
- Horizontal nystagmus beating toward the ground on both sides
- Stronger response on one side (the affected ear)
- Vertigo that correlates with nystagmus
- Classic latency and duration
Treatment: BBQ Roll maneuver (Lempert 360° rotation), which I can usually perform immediately after diagnosis. Success rate: 50-90% with 1-3 treatment sessions.
Positive Test for Apogeotropic HC-BPPV
Findings:
- Horizontal nystagmus beating away from the ground on both sides
- Weaker response on the affected side
- May have more persistent symptoms
Treatment: Gufoni maneuver or head-shake/vibration techniques to convert apogeotropic to geotropic before performing BBQ Roll. This variant sometimes requires more treatment sessions.
Negative Supine Roll Test
If both the Dix-Hallpike and Supine Roll tests are negative, I’ll consider:
- Vestibular migraine (most common cause of episodic vertigo after BPPV)
- Vestibular neuritis (acute onset, constant vertigo)
- Meniere’s disease (vertigo + hearing loss + tinnitus + ear fullness)
- Central causes requiring imaging (MRI brain)
- Persistent Postural-Perceptual Dizziness (PPPD)
At Prime ENT Center, I have comprehensive VNG testing capabilities to identify these alternative diagnoses.
đ„ Complete Vestibular Workup Available
If you need more than bedside testing, Dr. Porwal offers:
- â VNG (Videonystagmography) with caloric testing
- â vHIT (Video Head Impulse Test)
- â VEMP testing for superior canal dehiscence
- â Audiometry for Meniere’s disease workup
Treatment After Positive Supine Roll Test
One of the advantages of horizontal canal BPPV is that, like posterior canal BPPV, I can often treat it immediately after diagnosis.
For Geotropic HC-BPPV (Most Common)
First-line treatment: BBQ Roll Maneuver
- 360-degree rotation of your body while lying down
- Completed in 4 steps, 90 degrees at a time
- Each position held for 30 seconds
- Usually perform 2-3 complete rotations per session
- Success rate: 50-70% after first session, 85-95% after 2-3 sessions
Alternative: Forced Prolonged Position
- Sleep on the unaffected side for 12 hours
- Allows gravity to move crystals back to the utricle
- Success rate: 60-90% but requires patient compliance
For Apogeotropic HC-BPPV (Less Common)
First-line treatment: Gufoni Maneuver
- Side-lying maneuver that converts cupulolithiasis to canalithiasis
- Often followed by BBQ Roll
- May require head shaking or mastoid vibration
- Sometimes needs multiple sessions
Post-Treatment Instructions
After HC-BPPV treatment:
- First 24 hours: Avoid lying flat if possible; sleep with head elevated
- First night: Some experts recommend sleeping on the unaffected side (though evidence is mixed)
- Activity: No restrictions on daily activities; staying active is generally beneficial
- Follow-up: Return in 1 week if symptoms persist
Why Horizontal Canal BPPV Can Be Tricky
Higher Recurrence Rate
HC-BPPV tends to recur more frequently than posterior canal BPPV, with recurrence rates as high as 30-40% within the first year. This may be because:
- The horizontal canal’s anatomy makes crystal migration easier
- Crystals can more easily re-enter the canal from the utricle
- Treatment success may be less durable
Canal Conversion
Sometimes during treatment or even spontaneously, horizontal canal BPPV can convert to posterior canal BPPV (or vice versa). This is called “canal conversion” and happens because the canals are connectedâcrystals can migrate from one canal to another.
If this happens, I simply diagnose the new canal involvement with the appropriate test and treat accordingly.
Bilateral HC-BPPV
About 10% of HC-BPPV cases are bilateral (both ears affected). The Supine Roll Test may show similar intensity nystagmus on both sides, making it challenging to determine which ear to treat first. In these cases, I use additional clues like:
- Patient’s subjective report of which side feels worse
- Subtle differences in nystagmus intensity or duration
- VNG testing with quantitative measurements
How do I know if I need a Supine Roll Test?
Q: Why didn’t my first doctor do this test?
A: Many general practitioners and even some ENT specialists only perform the Dix-Hallpike test, which misses horizontal canal BPPV. As a fellowship-trained vestibular specialist, I routinely perform both tests on all BPPV patients to ensure accurate diagnosis of all canal variants.
Q: Can horizontal canal and posterior canal BPPV happen at the same time?
A: Yes, though it’s uncommon (about 5-10% of cases). This is called “multi-canal BPPV.” I treat the more symptomatic canal first, allow it to resolve, then treat the second canal. Treating both simultaneously can be confusing and uncomfortable.
Q: Is the Supine Roll test uncomfortable?
A: If you have HC-BPPV, yesâyou’ll experience vertigo during the test. Many patients report that horizontal canal BPPV causes more intense vertigo than posterior canal BPPV. However, the vertigo is brief (10-60 seconds) and necessary to confirm the diagnosis and determine the correct treatment.
Q: How accurate is the Supine Roll test?
A: The Supine Roll test has excellent sensitivity (approximately 90%) and specificity (>95%) for horizontal canal BPPV when performed by an experienced clinician. Accuracy improves when I use infrared video goggles (available through VNG testing) to detect subtle nystagmus.
Q: What if the test is negative but I still have dizziness when rolling in bed?
A: Several possibilities: (1) The timing might be offâotoconia might not be positioned to trigger symptoms during testing; (2) You might have a central vestibular disorder mimicking BPPV; (3) You might have vestibular migraine; (4) You might have PPPD (functional dizziness). I would recommend comprehensive VNG testing and possibly brain imaging.
Q: Can I do this test at home?
A: While you can try the head-turning movements, you cannot observe your own nystagmus, which is the key diagnostic finding. More importantly, if you have a central cause of vertigo rather than BPPV, you could injure yourself. Always have this test performed by a qualified healthcare provider.
Q: What’s the difference between geotropic and apogeotropic, and why does it matter?
A: Geotropic means the nystagmus beats toward the ground (crystals floating in the canal), while apogeotropic means it beats away from the ground (crystals stuck to the cupula). This matters tremendously because they require completely different treatments. Geotropic responds to BBQ Roll, while apogeotropic often needs Gufoni maneuver first.
Q: How long does the test take?
A: The Supine Roll test itself takes about 3-5 minutes (both sides with recovery time). Including history, examination, and treatment, your total appointment time is usually 20-30 minutes.
Q: Why does horizontal canal BPPV cause more intense vertigo?
A: The horizontal canal is oriented in a plane that’s particularly sensitive to head movements we make commonly (rolling in bed, turning our head while lying down). Additionally, the canal’s anatomy allows otoconia to move more easily, creating more vigorous cupular deflection and more intense symptoms.
Q: Can horizontal canal BPPV resolve on its own?
A: Yes, like all forms of BPPV, horizontal canal BPPV can spontaneously resolve as crystals naturally migrate back to the utricle. However, this can take weeks to months, and treatment provides much faster relief (often within 1-2 days).
Q: Should I avoid sleeping on one side after treatment?
A: This is debated among vestibular specialists. Some recommend sleeping on the unaffected side for 1-2 nights post-treatment, while recent studies suggest sleeping position may not significantly impact outcomes. I provide individualized recommendations based on the severity of your case and treatment response.
Why Choose Dr. Prateek Porwal for Horizontal Canal BPPV
As one of the few fellowship-trained vestibular specialists in Uttar Pradesh, I have extensive experience diagnosing and treating all variants of BPPV, including the less common horizontal canal type. My credentials include:
- â Fellowship Training: CAMVD (Clinical Approach to Manage Vestibular Disorders) from Yenepoya University
- â International Recognition: 1st Prize Young Researcher Award, VAI Budapest 2025
- â Advanced Equipment: VNG, vHIT, and posturography available at Prime ENT Center
- â Comprehensive Approach: All-canal BPPV diagnosis and treatment expertise
- â Same-Day Treatment: Most patients diagnosed and treated in single visit
đŻ Get Accurate Diagnosis for Your Vertigo
Don’t settle for incomplete testing. Horizontal canal BPPV is often missed by general practitioners.
đ Call Now: 7393062200
đ Book Online: drprateekporwal.com/book-consultation
đ Location: Prime ENT Center, Hardoi, Uttar Pradesh
Serving Hardoi, Lucknow, Kanpur, Kannauj, Farrukhabad, Shahjahanpur, and surrounding areas within 60km radius
Complete Vestibular Testing Available – Get All Answers in One Visit
Schedule Your Supine Roll Test Today â